Saturday, March 6, 2021

Collegium recalls nod for permanent posting

Must Read

Trump’s immigration policy was inhumane and ineffective: Jen Psaki

White House press secretary Jen Psaki on Friday defended President Joe Biden administration's immigration agenda as Republicans, including former...

Pakistan Hindu Family Members Killed; Multan Police Recovered Weapons Including A Knife And An Axe | पाकिस्तान के मुल्तान में हिंदू परिवार के 5...

Hindi NewsInternationalPakistan Hindu Family Members Killed; Multan Police Recovered Weapons Including A Knife And An AxeAds से है परेशान?...

Grave of slain “Everything will be OK” protester disturbed in Myanmar

March 6 (Reuters) - Guarded by police and soldiers, authorities in Myanmar disturbed the grave of a 19-year-old woman...

Uncertainty looms over future of Justice Pushpa Ganediwala of the Nagpur bench of the Bombay high court after the Supreme Court (SC) collegium, in an unprecedented step, has withdrawn its proposal to make her a permanent judge in the high court in view of her controversial rulings on sexual assault on children under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Pocso) Act.

Justice Ganediwala’s fate hangs in the balance since her tenure as an additional judge ends on February 12, and if the SC collegium, headed by Chief Justice of India SA Bobde, decides not to extend her term as an additional judge, she will cease to be a judge.

Under the constitutional provisions, an additional judge can be appointed for a maximum period of two years unlike permanent judges, who are appointed till the age of 62. Further, an additional judge can either be made permanent following a recommendation by the collegium, or the tenure can be extended as an additional judge for up to two years.

Justice Ganediwala has courted controversies after her judgments on interpretation of the Pocso Act came under criticism. In a January 19 ruling, she held that groping a minor without removing her clothes was not sexual assault but only molestation under IPC. This judgment was stayed by a Supreme Court bench, led by the CJI. In another judgment on January 15, the judge ruled that holding the hands of a minor and unzipping one’s trousers in front of her does not amount to “sexual assault”.

On Saturday, people in the law ministry and the Supreme Court confirmed to HT that the collegium has recalled its recommendation to make Justice Ganediwala a permanent judge. On January 20, the SC collegium passed a resolution, and the file reached law ministry a day later.

However, the people added, on January 25, a missive was sent by the SC collegium requesting for a withdrawal of the proposal. The note by the SC collegium stated that the proposal regarding the judge was to be reviewed again.

The law ministry then sent back the file with a note that the proposal was being returned on a request by the collegium and if a fresh proposal was to be sent again, the ministry will need around a week to process it.

“There has been no such instance when after sending a proposal to the government for appointing an additional judge as a permanent judge, the collegium has withdrawn its recommendation,” said a law ministry official familiar with the matter.

Former CJI KG Balakrishnan told HT: “…It is not a simple decision but if there is a judgment which is in flagrant violation of the law, a chief justice is entitled to not make an additional judge a permanent judge.”

app

Follow @ Facebook

Follow @ Twitter

Follow @ Telegram

Updates on Whatsapp – Coming Soon

Latest News

Rhea Chakraborty’s lawyer says they’ll have the ‘last laugh’, calls charge sheet ‘damp squib’

Actor Rhea Chakraborty's lawyer Satish Maneshinde has called the 12000-page charge sheet filed by the Narcotics Control Bureau in...

IT Raid: Actress Kangana Ranaut takes a direct dig at Taapsee Pannu, Says-You will always remain sasti because you are rapists ka feminist |...

Hindi NewsEntertainmentBollywoodIT Raid: Actress Kangana Ranaut Takes A Direct Dig At Taapsee Pannu, Says You Will Always Remain Sasti Because You Are Rapists Ka...

Little Janhvi Kapoor twirls in unseen childhood video shared by Khushi: ‘Happy birthday to my everything’

Janhvi Kapoor rang in her birthday on Saturday. On the occasion, the actor's sister Khushi took to Instagram and shared a video of a...

After controversies, Alia wants to stay with Nawazuddin siddiqui again, these celebs have also given their broken marriage a second chance | विवादों के...

Hindi NewsEntertainmentBollywoodAfter Controversies, Alia Wants To Stay With Nawazuddin Siddiqui Again, These Celebs Have Also Given Their Broken Marriage A Second ChanceAds से है...

Rhea Chakraborty’s Lawyer Satish Maneshinde Reacts On The Chargesheet Filed By Narkotics Controle Beauro In Drugs Angle Related To Sushant Singh Rajput Death Case...

Hindi NewsEntertainmentBollywoodRhea Chakraborty's Lawyer Satish Maneshinde Reacts On The Chargesheet Filed By Narkotics Controle Beauro In Drugs Angle Related To Sushant Singh Rajput Death...

More Articles Like This